Trust and fiduciary transactions. A still ongoing complex process: concise comparison between Italian and German systems
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54103/milanlawreview/19509Parole chiave:
Trust, Italian system, German SystemAbstract
Before The Hague Convention was signed (on 1st July 1985), it was not allowed to refer to any trust country’s law as a framework for domestic trusts having no international objective elements. The Hague Convention has instead allowed it, but it has also enabled its signatory Member Countries to outlaw any reference to such a framework (art. 13 The Hague Convention).Well, shortly after The Hague Convention came into force, Italy has instead largely acknowledged the legitimacy of domestic trusts, while extensively enforcing some domestic rules deemed to be binding under articles 15 and 18 of the Hague Convention. France’s and Germany’s approach have been different. France has ratified the Convention, but it has also enacted a trust-related law regulating any domestic fiduciary transactions (Act dated 19th February 2007. De la fiducie). Germany (which has not ratified The Hague Convention) has drawn up specific rules about fiduciary transactions, giving rise to an increasingly clear development over the last twenty years. Therefore, three different solutions to the same substantial problems in major Civil-law Countries. This essay outlines and focuses on the development of the German system.
Riferimenti bibliografici
Andres D., § 47 InsO, marginal number 38, in Nerlich/Römermann, Insolvenzordnung, C.H. Beck, München, 2019
Anelli F., L’alienazione in funzione di garanzia, Giuffré, Milan, 1996
Bernasconi P., Obblighi del trustee in diritto svizzero: novità legali e giurisprudenziali, in Trusts, 2020, p. 624
Braun A., I trust di garanzia in Germania, in Trusts 2000, p. 42 ff.
Brinkmann M., § 47 InsO marginal number 86, in Uhlenbruck, Insolvenzordnung, C.H. Beck, München, 2019
Busani A., Il Trust, istituzione, gestione, cessazione, Cedam, Padua, 2020
Dupichot P., Rapport de synthèse, in Association Henri Capitant, La fiducie dans tous ses états, Journée nationale, tome XV, Dalloz, Paris, 2011, p. 89 ff.
Calvo R., La proprietà del mandatario, Cedam, Padua, 1996
Gabrielli E., Sulle garanzie rotative, ESI, Naples, 1998
Gatt L., “Il “trust interno”, una questione ancora aperta. Dal trust al trust. Storia di una chimera, ESI, Naples, 2011
Gernhuber J., Die fiduziarische Treuhand, in IuS 98, Heft 5
Graziadei M., voce Mandato in diritto comparato, in Digesto delle Discipline Privatistiche, Sez. Civ., Vol. XI, UTET, Turin, 1994, p. 192 ff.
Grisel G., Le trust en Suisse, Schulthess Éd. Romandes, Genève, 2020
Henssler M., Treuhandsgeschäft-Dogmatik und Wirklichkeit, in Archiv für die civilistische Praxis (AcP), 1996, p. 37 ff.
Hirte H. - Praβ P.J., § 35 InsO marginal number 27, in Uhlenbruck, Insolvenzordnung, C.H. Beck, München, 2019
Jaeger P.G., Sull’intestazione fiduciaria di quote di S.r.l., in Giur. comm. 1979
Kieninger E.M. (co-edited with M. Graziadei; G.L. Gretton; C.G. Van der Merwe; M.E. Storme), Security Rights in Movable Property, in European Private Law, Cambridge University Press, 2004
Kötz H., Trust und Treuhand, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen, 1963
Lenders R, Treuhand am Gesellschaftsanteil, Peter Lang Verlag, Frankfurt u. Bern, 2004
Lupoi M., Il contratto di affidamento fiduciario, Giuffré, Milan, 2014
Lupoi M., Istituzioni del diritto del trust negli ordinamenti di origine e in Italia, IV Ed., Giuffré, Milan, 2020
Malaurie P. – Aynès L., Les biens, II Ed., Defrénois, Paris, 2005
Parodi N., Le operazioni fiduciarie, Giappichelli, Turin, 2018
Petrelli G., Destinazioni patrimoniali e trust, Giuffré, Milan, 2019
Petrelli G., Vincoli di destinazione ex art. 2645 ter c.c. e trust, quindici anni dopo, in Riv. Not. 2020, p.1901
Piepoli G., Garanzie sulle merci e spossessamento, Jovene, Naples, 1980
Portale G.B. and Ginevra E., Intestazione a società fiduciarie di azioni non interamente liberate e responsabilità per i conferimenti residui, in Studi P.G. JAEGER, Milan, 2011
Schäfer C., Münchener Kommentar zum BGB, 8. Auflage 2020, para. 31 ff.
Schubert C., in Münchener Kommentar zum BGB, München, 2018, para 51 ff.
Schurr F.A., La revoca del trustee e la sostituzione del medesimo con altro. Alcune riflessioni comparatistiche, in Trusts, 2021, p. 17 ff.
Semeraro M., Acquisti e proprietà nell’interesse del mandante, ESI, Naples, 2011
Serick R., Le garanzie mobiliari nel diritto tedesco, Giuffré, Milan, 1990, Verlag Recht und Wirtschaft, Heidelberg, 1988
Thevenoz L., Propositions pour un trust suisse, in Schweiz. Zeitschrift für Wirtschafts- und Finanzrecht, 2018
Walter G., Das Unmittelbarkeitsprinzip bei der fiduziarischen Treuhand, Moht Siebeck, Tübingen, 1974
Witz C., La fiducie en droit privé francais, Paris, 1980
Dowloads
Pubblicato
Fascicolo
Sezione
Licenza
Copyright (c) 2022 Milan Law Review
Questo lavoro è fornito con la licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 4.0 Internazionale.