Expressiveness. A methodological approach


  • Marco Franceschina Università Cattolica di Milano



The debate on expressiveness is one of the most relevant in contemporary aesthetics. In fact, the possibility of an emotional linguistic expression referring to artistic objects or natural situations crosses a number of themes of classical and analytical aesthetics. The aim of this essay is therefore to enucleate what the presuppositions of a theory of expressiveness should be, starting from their historical genesis in the «expression theory» elaborated by Dewey. In particular, through the critical examination of two contemporary orientations on this issue – the Wollheim projectivist theory and the profile one by Kivy –, the aim is to bring attention to two indispensable aspects of a theory of expressiveness, which, although in need of revision, were already recognizable in the expression theory: a. a theory of intentionality and b. the dialectical consideration between Leib and Körper. In particular, the direction sketched at the end would suggest that it is this dialectical experience of the body that could be considered as the intentional condition for the existence and recognizability of expressive phenomena.

Riferimenti bibliografici


Benenti, M., Expressiveness. Perception and Emotions in the Experience of Expressive Objects, De Gruyer, Berlin 2020.

Benenti, M., e Matteo Ravasio. Introduzione, in M. Benenti e M. Ravasio (ed. by) Espressività. Un dibattito contemporaneo, Mimesis, Milano 2017, pp.7-18.

Bozzi, P., Tertiary qualities, in I. Bianchi e R. Davies (ed. by) Paolo Bozzi's Experimental phenomenology, New York, Routledge 2019.

Budd, M., Wollheim on Correspondence, Projective Properties, and Expressive Perception, in R. van Gerwen (ed. by), Richard Wollheim on the Art of Painting: Art Representation and Expression, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2001, pp.101-111.

Capra, S., Il problema del linguaggio in Maurice Merleau-Ponty, in “Rivista di filosofia Neo-Scolastica”, LXIV/23, 1972, pp.446-470.

Carbone, M., Prefazione. Il mondo sensibile è (già) mondo dell’espressione, in M. Merleau-Ponty Il mondo sensibile e il mondo dell’espressione, Mimesis, Milano 2021, pp.9-16.

Carreno, F. P., La percezione espressiva della natura e dell'arte, in M. Benenti e M. Ravasio (ed. by) Espressività. Un dibattito contemporaneo, Mimesis, Milano 2017, pp.93-116.

Colli, F., Prandoni A., L'essere a due facce, Mimesis, Milano 2002.

Collingwood, R. G., The principles of art (1958), Oxford University Press, Oxford 1968.

Croce, B., Estetica (1902), Aldelphi, Milano 1990.

Dalmasso, C., Introduzione. Cinetica dell’espressione, in M. Merleau-Ponty Il mondo sensibile e il mondo dell’espressione, cit., pp.16-52.

Dewey, J., Art as experience (1934), Perigee Book, New York 1980.

Diodato, R., Logos estetico, Morcelliana, Brescia 2012.

Esrock, J., Einfühlung as the Breath of Art: Six Modes of Embodiment, in “Cognitive Processing”, XIX/2, pp.187-199.

Forlè, F., Qualità terziarie. Saggio sulla fenomenologia sperimentale, Franco Angeli, Milano 2018.

Frattaroli, F., Corpo della parola, corpo del senso: espressione e pensiero in M. Merleau-Ponty, in “Studi di Estetica”, XLIX/2, 2021, pp.51-69.

Goodman, N., Languages of art (1968), Hackett, Indiana 2022.

Granger, D., Expression, Imagination, and Organic Unity: John Dewey's Aesthetics and Romanticism, The Journal of Aesthetic Education, XXXVII/2, 2003, pp.46-60.

Griffero, T., Condannati al senso (e all'espressione). Otto tesi sulle atmosfere come insiemi espressivi, in M. Benenti e M. Ravasio (ed. by) Espressività. Un dibattito contemporaneo, Mimesis, Milano 2017, pp.169-196.

Griffero, T., Il corpo (proprio) rappresentato, in “Teorie e Modelli”, XV/2-3, 2010, pp.241-257.

Hospers, J., The Concept of Artistic Expression, in “Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society”, LV, 1954-1955, pp.313-344.

Husserl, H., Idee per una fenomenologia pura e una filosofia fenomenologica (1912-1929), libro II, transl. by E. Filippini, Einaudi, Torino 1965.

Husserl, H., Lezioni sulla sintesi passiva (1918-1926), transl. by V. Costa, la scuola, Brescia 2016.

Husserl, H., Logica formale e trascendentale (1929), transl. by G.D. Neri, Laterza, Bari 1966.

Kemp, G., The Croce-Collingwood Theory as Theory, in “The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism”, LX/2, 2003.

Kivy, P., The Corded Shell – Reflections on Musical Expression, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2018.

Kivy, P., Introduction to a Philosophy of music (1998), Oxford University Press 2002.

Locke, J., Saggio sull'intelletto umano (1690), transl. by V. Cicero e M. G. D'Amico, Bompiani, Milano 2007.

Merleau-Ponty, M., Phenomenologie de la perception (1945), Gallimard, Paris 2001.

Merleau-Ponty, M., Le doute de Cèzanne (1948), in M. Merleau-Ponty Sens et non-sens, Gallimard, Paris 1966, pp.9-33.

Merleau-Ponty, M., Le langage indirect et le voix du silence, in Signes (1952), Folio, Paris 2016.

Merleau-Ponty, M., Le monde sensible et le monde de l’expression (1953), Metis Press, Genève 2011.

Merleau-Ponty, M., Le visible et l'invisible (1964), Gallimard, Paris 2016.

Merleau-Ponty, M., L’oeil et l’esprit (1964), Folio, Paris 2007.

Merleau-Ponty, M., Résumés de cours. Collège de France, 1952-1960, Gallimard, Paris 1968.

Nolan, L., Primary and Secondary qualities. The Historical and Ongoing Debate, University Press Oxford, Oxford 2011.

Robinson, J., Expression and Expressiveness in Art, «Postgraduate Journal of Aesthetics, IV/2, 2007, pp.19-41.

Rozzoni, C., A Husserlian Approach to Aesthetic Experience:Existential Disinterest and Axiological Interest, in “Phenomenon”, 29, (2019), pp.115-133.

Rozzoni, C., Am I Truly Feeling This? Quasi-Emotions and Quasi-Values in Cinematic Experience¸ in Thiemo Breyer Marco Cavallaro Rodrigo Y. Sandoval (ed. by) Phenomenology of Phantasy and Emotion, WBg, Darmstadt 2022, pp.181-206.

Sinico, M., Tertiary qualities, from Galileo to Gestalt Psycology, in “History of Human Sciences”, XXVIII/3, 2015, pp.68-79.

Sircello, G., Mind and Art: an Essay on the Varieties of Expression, Princeton University Press, Princeton 1972.

Spinicci, P., Dieci lezioni sulle proprietà espressive, 2017. (consultato il giorno 04 17, 2022).

Spinicci, P., Fenomeni e manifestazioni espressive, in M. Benenti e M. Ravasio (ed. by) Espressività. Un dibattito contemporaneo, Mimesis, Milano 2017, pp.145-168.

Todd, G. F., Expression without feeling, in “The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism”, XXX/4, 1972, pp.477-488.

Tormey, A., The concept of Expression: a Study in Philosophical Psycology and Aesthetics, Princeton University Press, Princeton 1971.

Vanzago, L., Metamorfosi. La questione dell'espressione nella filosofia di Merleau-Ponty, in “Lebenswelt”, 9, 2016, pp.31-47.

Wollheim, R., Correspondence, Projective Properties, and Expression in the Arts, in R. Wollheim The mind and Its Depths, Harvard University Press, Cambridge Massachusetts 1993, pp.144-158.





Aesthetics, Technique and Emotion (ed. by A. Barale, C. Rozzoni)