Logic of deviations. From magical thinking to empirical science
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54103/2039-9251/20834Keywords:
Anomaly, Tremendus, double monsters, portentuos, error.Abstract
This essay aims to deal with early forms of skepticism, which naturalized the animal Kingdom by removing it from the moral sphere of religious spiritualism.
In the 17th century, the gradual shift from magical thinking to science had important implications in the study of monsters.
Starting from the concept of anomaly, we define a new science of life where monsters dwel. We deal with human phenomena, the tremendus, described and explained as deviations from the norm, errors. In the second half of the 17th century, the most important Academies began to devote themselves to the study of portentuos marvels and the debate on monsters became central in Natural Science: it was during this period that monsters were placed on anatomical tables in order to be dissected and classified. Fundamental in this regard were the studies of the surgeon John Hunter, in whose collection we can admire numerous specimens of so-called double monsters. In the 18th century, thanks to the numerous studies by Étienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire and his son Isidore, we arrive at the new vision of monstruosities, finally considered as sufficient in themselves, as autonomous abjects and therefore concrete, accessible and observable. Finally, I will discuss the special relationship between science and spectacle, public an private. The monster embodies a very strong aesthetic end attractive power: the image is the most suitable medium for describing it.
References
Accarino, B., Zoologia politica. Favole, mostri e macchine, Mimesis, Milano, 2013.
Asma, S. T., On Monsters. An Unnatural History of our Worst Fears, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2009.
Bory de Saint Vincent, M., Dictionnaire Classique d’Histoire Naturelle, Biodiversity Heritage Library (open access digital library), Paris, 1822.
Canguilhem, G., Il normale e il patologico, trad. it. D. Buzzolan, Einaudi, Torino, 1998.
Daston, L., e Park, K., Le meraviglie del mondo. Mostri, prodigi e fatti strani dal Medioevo all’Illuminismo, trad. it. di M. Ferraro e B. Valotti, Carocci, Roma,1998.
De Vecchi, B., Teratologia generale, Utet, Torino, 1923.
Fadini, U., Negri, A., Wolfe, C. T. (a cura di), Desiderio del mostro. Dal circo al laboratorio alla politica, trad. it. di V. Bianco, G. Nicolemi e S. Talluri, Manifestolibri, Roma, 2001.
Haraway, D., Testimone- modesta@Femaleman- incontra -Oncotopo. Femminismo e tecnoscienza, trad. it. di M. Morganti, Feltrinelli, Milano, 2000.
Kappler, C. C., Demoni, mostri e meraviglie alla fine del Medioevo, a cura di F. Carolini, Jouvence, Milano, 2019.
Klossowsky, P., Il mostro, in G. Bataille, La congiura sacra, trad. it. di F. Di Stefano, Bollati Boringhieri, Torino, 1977 (pp. 8-11).
Le Guyarder, H., Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire. Un Naturaliste Visionnaire, Belin, Paris, 2017.
Mamet, D., Some Freaks, Penguin Grove, New York, 1989.
Mazzocut-Mis, M., Anatomia del mostro. Antologia di scritti di Etienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire e Isidore, La Nuova Italia, Firenze, 1995.
Mazzocut-Mis, M., Gli enigmi della forma. Un’indagine morfologica tra biologia ed estetica a partire dal pensiero di D’Arey W. Thompson, CUEM, Milano, 2002.
Mazzocut-Mis, M., Monstre. E. G. Saint-Hilaire and the Science of Monstruosity, in “Medicina nei secoli, arte e scienza”, Journal of History of Medicine, Voll. 26, n. 1, 2014 (pp. 145-165).
Mazzocut-Mis, M., Il mostro. L’anomalo e il deforme nella natura e nell’arte, Ed. Angelo Guerini, Milano, 1992.
Parè, A., Conseiller et Premier Chirurgien du Roy, avec les figures et portraicts tout de Anatomie que es instrument de Chirurgie et de Plusieurs monstres, Chez Gabriel Buon, Paris, 1575.
Saint-Hilaire, G., É., Etudes Progressives d’un Naturaliste pendant les annèes 1834 et 1838, Chez Rorer, Paris, 1835.
Saint-Hilaire, G. É., Philosophie Anatomique. Monstrositès Humaines, J. B. Ballière, Paris, 1772.
Saint-Hilaire, G. I., Essays de zoologie gènèrale, ou Mèmoires et notices sur la Zoologie gènèrale, l’Antropologie et l’Histoire de la science, Rocket, Paris, 1841.
Saint-Hilaire, G. I., Histoire gènèrale des Anomalies et particulière de l’organisation chez les Animaux ou Traitè de Tèratologie, Rey et Gravier, Paris, 1827.
Saint-Hilaire, G. É. et Cuvier, F., Histoire Naturelle des Mammifères, avec des figures originales Enluminèes, desinèes, d’apres desanimaux vivants, M. C. De Lasteyrie Ed., Paris, 1820.
Downloads
Published
Versions
- 2023-10-20 (2)
- 2023-08-08 (1)
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Marina Mascherini
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
The authors who publish in Itinera are required to accept the following conditions:
1. The authors retain the rights on their paper and lincese the journal the right of first publication. The paper is also licensed under a Creative Commons License, which allows others to share it, by indicating intellectual authorship and its first publication in Itinera.
2. Authors may adhere to other non-exclusive license agreements for the distribution of the published version of the paper (ex. deposit it in an institutional archive or publish it in a monograph), provided that its first publication in Itinera is indicated.
3. Authors can disseminate their paper online (ex. in institutional repositories or on their website) before and during the submission process, since this can lead to productive exchanges and increase quotations of the published work (See “The Effect of Open Access”).