Transculturality of the Alps: The Role of Image and Sound in a European “Multiple Bergfilm” of the 1930s

Authors

  • Maria Adorno Universities of Köln
  • Maria Fuchs University of Music and Performing Arts Vienna

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54103/2036-461X/17960

Keywords:

Mountain Films, Multiple Versions, Luis Trenker, Transculturality, Alps

Abstract

The discovery of the Alps in the specific genre of the mountain film was originally a German answer to the Westerns from the USA in the late 1920s. This brought a number of important personalities such as Fanck, Riefenstahl and Trenker onto the German film market, though the genre developed in different ways in other contexts, too. The mountain film Der Sohn der weißen Berge / Les Chevaliers de la Montagne by Trenker and Bonnard was coproduced as a German-French multiple version (MV) in 1930 and represents the beginning of a longer series of ‘multiple’ coproductions by Trenker. During the generalization of sound, MVs are meant to create the ‘same’ film for each country interested in it. In order to make the versions successful in their contexts, each of them is shaped according to early audio-visual techniques and adapting elements such as cast, fictional nationalities, music, dialogues or gestures. This article aims to approach the two MVs from a comparative, transcultural perspective in order to highlight their specificities. The aim is to investigate the transcultural character of the Alps arguing that, due to their semantic openness, the Alps provide an ideal setting for transcultural communication and for the nationalization process essential to the MVs. As a territory at the crossroad of several countries and cultures, the Alpine environment proves through Der Sohn der weißen Berge / Les Chevaliers de la Montagne to be a privileged territory for multiplecinematic cultural transfers that contribute to the establishment of European cinema.

Author Biographies

Maria Adorno, Universities of Köln

Maria Adorno is a PhD candidate in history of cinema at the Universities of Köln, Udine and Lyon 2 (“Doctor Europaeus” project, DAAD scholarship). She previously studied philosophy of cinema and European film studies at the Universities of Torino, Lyon, Utrecht and Weimar. Her current research involves the multiple versions of the early sound film history within the European context (see Revue d’Allemagne et des pays de langue allemande | 54-2, 2022). She analyses the transcultural dimension of the multiple versions with a comparative, multilingual approach to both films and trade press. She has given several talks at international conferences and she is associate director of the Karlsruhe Silent-Film Festival.

Maria Fuchs, University of Music and Performing Arts Vienna

Maria Fuchs is a Senior Postdoc at the University of Music and Performing Arts Vienna and heads the FWF-funded project "Soundscapes of 'Heimat': Mapping Musical Signatures in Heimatfilm and Bergfilm (1930-1970)". She studied musicology, comparative literature and gender studies at the University of Vienna and the Free University of Berlin. From 2012 to 2014, she held doctoral fellowships from the University of Vienna and the DAAD, with a study and research stay at the Department for Musicology and Media Studies at Humboldt University, PhD in 2015. Research and teaching stations: Centre for Popular Culture and Music in Freiburg, University of Music and Performing Arts Vienna, Berlin University of the Arts, University of Salzburg, Deutsche Kinemthek and Deutsches Filminstitut und Filmmuseum in Frankfurt am Main. Her research interests are Screen Music and Sound, Music Aesthetics, Theory of Film Music and Popular Cultures and Postcolonial Music Practices.

References

“Bergspitzen ohne Menuett. Musik ums Matterhorn.” n. d. in Der Berg ruft. Ein Matterhornfilm von Luis Trenker, edited by Günter Zoellner. Pressedienst der Terra Filmkunst G.m.b.H., no pag.

“‘Chez Vandal et Delac’ and ‘Les films du mois – Production française.” 1930. Le Cinéopse: 135: 414–415.

“Febbrile attività degli Italiani all'Estero Pro Cinematografia Internazionale. Avant-Première dei Cavalieri della Montagna.” 1930. Cine-Sorriso Illustrato: 6.

Altman, Rick. 1999. Film/Genre. London: BFI.

Antonini, Anna, ed. 2003. Il film e I suoi multipli / Film and Its Multiples. Udine: Forum.

Audisio, Aldo, ed. 1995. Cinema delle Montagne. Dizionario museo montagna, 4000 film a soggetto, montagna, alpinismo, esplorazione, poli e regioni artiche. Turin: Utet Libreria.

Baer, Nicholas. 2016. “Natural History: Rethinking the Bergfilm.” Kulturelle Figurationen: Artefakte, Praktiken, Fiktionen, edited by Jörn Ahrens et al., 279–306. Wiesbaden: Springer.

Barnier, Martin. 2004. Des films français made in Hollywood: Les versions multiples 1929-1935. Paris: L’Harmattan.

Barnier, Martin. 2013. “Versions multiples et langues en Europe.” Mise au Point, 5. doi: https://doi.org/10.4000/map.1490.

Bessy, Maurice. 1931. “De la vie à l’écran ou la métamorphose des vedettes”. Cinémonde 122:125

Bush, Alex. 2019. “Moving Mountains: Glacial Contingency and Modernity in the Bergfilm”. Journal of Cinema and Media Studies 59 (1): 1–22.

Calabretto, Roberto. 2004. “Due versioni musicali a confronto. Die Dreigroschenoper e L’Opera de quat’sous di Georg Wilhelm Pabst.” Cinéma & Cie 4 (1): 30–48;

Distelmeyer, Jan. 2006. Babylon in FilmEuropa: Mehrsprachen-Versionen der 1930er Jahre. Munich: CineGraph.

Felsch, Philipp. 2007. Laborlandschaften. Physiologische Alpenreisen im 19. Jahrhundert. Göttingen: Wallstein.

Fenoli, Marc. 2009. “La montagne en scène.” La montagne et l'Alpinisme 3: 38–45.

Garncarz, Joseph. 2013. Wechselnde Vorlieben: über die Filmpräferenzen der Europäer 1896-1939. Frankfurt am Main: Stroemfeld / Nexus.

Giesen, Roman. 2008. “Der Bergfilm der 20er und 30er Jahre.” Medienobservationen, Medien Observationen .

Haver, Gianni. 2005. “Città e montagna nel Bergfilm europeo tra le due guerre.” Memoria e Ricerca 19: 129–136.

Ichac, Marcel. 1960. Quand brillent les étoiles de midi. Grenoble: Arthaud.

Ingeborg, Zechner. 2022. “Multiple-Music Versions? A German Sound Film-Operetta and Its Versions for France and Italy.” Music, Sound & the Moving Image 15 (2): 133–166.

Kamaal Haque. 2013. From Der Berg ruft to The Challenge: Adapting a Bergfilm for the English Market. Seminar: A Journal of Germanic Studies 49 (4): 414–427.

Kant, Immanuel. 1974. Kritik der Urteilskraft, edited by Wilhelm Weischedel. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.

Koepnick, Lutz. 2002. The Dark Mirror, German Cinema between Hitler and Hollywood. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Kracauer, Siegfried. 2017. Von Caligari zu Hitler. Eine psychologische Geschichte des deutschen Films. Translated by Ruth Baumgarten and Karsten Witte. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp.

Mantovani, Roberto. 2020. Action: Let’s Climb! History of Mountaineering and Climbing Film. Turin: C.A.I. – Club Alpino Italiano.

Müller, Corinna. 2003. Vom Stummfilm zum Tonfilm. München: Wilhelm Fink.

O’Brien, Charles. 2006. “Versionen, Radio und Grammophon. Die 3-Groschen-Oper und L’Opéra de Quat’Sous.” Babylon in FilmEuropa. Mehrsprachen-Versionen der 1930er Jahre, edited by Jan Distelmeyer, 123–132. München: CineGraph.

Peabody, Seth. 2021. “Image, Environment, Infrastructure: The Social Ecologies of the Bergfilm.” Humanities 10 (38): 1–18. doi: 10.3390/h10010038.

Peck, Robert E. 2007. “Film Music in The Third Reich.” Composing for the Screen in Germany and the USSR: Cultural Politics and Propaganda, edited by Robyn J. Stilwell and Phil Powrie, 19–38. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

Rentschler, Eric. 1990. “Mountain and Modernity: Relocating the Bergfilm’.” New German Critique 51 (4): 137–161.

Rousseau, Jean-Jacques. 1978 [1761]. Julie oder Die Neue Héloïse. Briefe zweier Liebenden aus einer kleinen Stadt am Fuße der Alpen, translated by Johann Gottfried Cellius, Münich: Rellstab.

Schrader, Sabine, and Daniel Winkler. 2018. “Maciste (1915–1926). Ein früher Muskelmann als nationaler Serienheld. Bartolomeo Pagano, Körperkulut und Starkult’.” Serialität und Moderne: Feuilleton, Stummfilm, Avantgarde, edited by Daniel Winkler et.al., 151–176. Bielefeld: transcript 2018.

Schriftsteller Luis Trenker. Wien: Universität Wien.

Simmel, Georg. 1919. “Die Alpen.” Philosophische Kultur: Gesammelte Essais von Georg Simmel, 138. Leipzig: Alfred Körner Verlag.

Sontag, Susan. 1981. “Fascinating Facisms.” Under the Sign of Saturn: 73–109. New York: Vintage.

Stern, Frank. 2001. “Film in the 1950s: Passing Images of Guilt and Responsibility.” The Miracle Years. A Cultural History of West Germany 1949–1968, edited by Hanna Schissler, 266–280. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Von Haller, Albrecht. 2006. “Die Alpen.” In Versuch Schweizerischer Gedichte, edited by Robert Barth et al., 21–58. Zürich: Olms.

Von Moltke, Johannes. 2002. “Evergreens: The Heimat Genre.” The German Cinema Book, edited by Tim Bergfelder, Erica Carter and Deniz Göktürk, 14–28. London: British Film Institute.

Downloads

Published

2023-09-22

How to Cite

Adorno, M., & Fuchs, M. (2023). Transculturality of the Alps: The Role of Image and Sound in a European “Multiple Bergfilm” of the 1930s. Cinéma & Cie. Film and Media Studies Journal, 23(40), 141–164. https://doi.org/10.54103/2036-461X/17960